He used the example from the Surat Basin, in northern NSW-southern Queensland, as an example of where it brings together companies, communities, local government and traditional owners, to create conversations and an environment to create ‘good’.
“If a company hasn’t signed up to be part of the compact and isn’t contributing to it, then you can assume it’s not acting in good faith and isn’t interested in good, so you would treat it as almost a hostile company,” he said.
Mr Sounness outlined data showing that farmland – value of the land and the production – had increased 800 per cent in the 20 years, but there was a decreasing population in the region.
He said the community was asked to ‘wear the risk’ because housing and workforce solutions was ‘settled very late’ in the development of the projects.
“If these projects matter to the nation, the communities that have to host them or want to host them, shouldn’t be left worse off,” he said.
“At the moment, nothing requires housing and workforce plans to ensure that local communities benefit in a meaningful way.”
Food security
Mr Sounness said the rehabilitation of the land – and from an agricultural perspective the yield that a crop would produce – from mining operations was of particular interest to farmers.
“We’ve done a lot of food-security work in the last 12 months, and food security preparedness is a north-star issue for this region as agriculture is the hero part of our economy,” he said.
“We found that land use and who gets to decide how land is used is one of the big vulnerabilities in our regional food production systems.”
Mr Sounness likened critical mineral companies as ‘start-up businesses’ with little or no initial cash-flow.
“But I think that’s probably poorly designed business development. They’re almost asking the rural communities to subsidise their business development,” he said.
“I see this regional compact an investment companies should be making as part of their business development costs, and they should be budgeting for it.”
When asked by the panel if the region would be worse off for the proposed mining projects, Mr Sounness said from a regional development perspective, the region needed diversity in its economy.
“Can I say we’ll be definitely better off? No, because the future is uncertain,” he said.
“But more of the same in our community, we can’t go on with more of the same – that much I do know because our community will be far worse off if we continue on the trajectory we’re on.”
Mr Sounness said the community, as a whole, did not have trust in the projects, with many people viewing the amount of proposed jobs on offer as a threat to existing businesses, rather than an opportunity.
Mr Tudball, also representing RDA Loddon-Mallee, said there were 11 planned mineral sands projects across the two regions capable of delivering up to 7000 regional jobs.
He said the region sat on ‘globally-significant deposits of critical minerals, holding 39 per cent of Australian zircon, 51 per cent of our rutile and substantial deposits of rare earths and lithium’.
“With that being said, we understand where government is going, and we’re not here to talk about the policy as in so much the mineral sands, and I certainly acknowledge the angst, emotion and concern in community that we’ve heard for the last few years about that,” he said.
“We believe the critical minerals are transformational asset, but it can’t be at the expense of the local community.
“We believe without deliberate tripartite government co-ordination – federal, state, and local – that it could strip out the land of our region, particularly the workforce and the housing, and leave us with no legacy and also a fly-in, fly-out culture because of the lack of workforce here.”
Mr Tudball said RDA Grampians’ submission outlined the need for companies to invest in economic value-adding beyond the extraction only.
“Yes, we need housing. Yes, we need workforce to do that, but we need investment and we need a co-ordination from governments to be able to do that,” he said.
“Where does it leave our agricultural sector? We need to work together on how we can do that.
“One of the ways is designating our area as a regional workforce priority area, and we believe government can do that.”
Mr Tudball said proponents’ community benefit funds were crucial, with local government not benefiting financially from the projects.
He said six of the nine local governments in the region collected the lowest rates in all of Victoria, and could not afford to be left with the costs of infrastructure such as roads, which would be affected by the projects.
When the panel asked why he thought the region had formed a ‘less than excellent’ experience in how mineral sands mining operations had commenced, Mr Tudball said it was ‘history and trust’.
He spoke about Iluka mining near Ouyen and having a separation plant at Hamilton.
“This part of the world seemed to be getting dudded from getting nothing out of it, yet all of the workforce was down in Hamilton,” he said.
“The mining is place-based. The infrastructure that’s required needs to be place-based and you’d argue that significant other workforce, including executive jobs and everything should be place-based.”
Mr Tudball said the future of the region – particularly smaller towns – looked ‘a little bleak’ if the mining operations did not proceed as agricultural – as important as it was to the region – was not the highest employer.
The entire October 28, 2026 edition of The Weekly Advertiser is available online. READ IT HERE!
The entire October 29, 2026 edition of AgLife is available online. READ IT HERE!