Cr Milne said the council had previously raised concerns with VicGrid about undertaking consultation with farmers during the harvest period.
“Just as our farmers are gearing up for a very busy harvest season, VicGrid has put out its 9690-page EES,” he said.
“How are our farmers meant to read and understand this incredibly lengthy document at the same time as bringing the harvest in?
“We have told VicGrid repeatedly to avoid holding consultation during harvest, and they keep ignoring us.”
Cr Milne said the council was also concerned about the timing of the exhibition in the lead-up to next month’s state election.
“The election result could mean that VNI West is over. Despite that, VicGrid is asking farmers and residents to spend their valuable time reviewing their massive report and making submissions on a project that may not proceed,” he said.
“We do not need this added pressure on farmers.”
Cr Milne said the council would make a formal submission outlining its concerns with the VNI West project.
Meanwhile, VFF president and Minyip farmer Ryan Milgate said the EES presented a misleading picture of the cost the project would have on Victoria’s agricultural industry.
Mr Milgate said it estimated a total of $2.77-million in lost agricultural production during the three-and-a-half-year construction period across 209 farming properties.
“The $2.77-million figure does not come close to representing the real cost of VNI West to farmers,” he said.
“It is an estimate of production lost during construction and only on the 70-metre-wide easement itself.
“It does not account for the ongoing impact of putting a major transmission line through working farms for the next 50 to 100 years.
“These are businesses that have been carefully designed around paddock layouts, cropping rotations, livestock movements, irrigation, machinery access and farm infrastructure.
“Once you put towers and a transmission easement through that system, you permanently change the way those farms operate and the impact compounds.”
Mr Milgate said inefficient paddock layouts, changes to livestock movements, restrictions on machinery operation and ongoing access requirements were among the issues the project could create for farmers.
“These projects can’t even estimate the cost of the poles and wires they intend to install accurately, so it’s a bit rich to expect any trust in the estimate of how much they think their impact will hit the bottom lines of farm businesses,” he said.
“These impacts don’t disappear when construction finishes. They become part of the farm.”
Mr Milgate’s words echoed those of Marnoo farmer Ben Duxson at Friday’s protest in Melbourne.
“VNI West … is an unnecessary project. We do not need these projects out there,” he said.
“We’ll fight back. We’re not standing down.”
The EES was published on October 5 and is open for submissions until November 16. People can view the statement and make submissions online via engage.vic.gov.au/VNI-West-IAC.
– Colin MacGillivray
The entire October 14, 2026 edition of The Weekly Advertiser is available online. READ IT HERE!